Wednesday, September 10, 2014

Top economists say there’s something ‘very fishy’ about Statistics Canada’s August jobs report

 |  | Last Updated: Sep 5 12:28 PM ET
More from Financial Post Staff
"Apparently private payroll employees were just crushed last month via a drop of 97,800 and this was almost fully offset by a coincidental surge of 86,900 in the number of self-employed," said Scotiabank's Derek Holt in a note to clients Friday. "That’s statistically possible I suppose but it looks very fishy to me."
THE CANADIAN PRESS/Ryan Remiorz"Apparently private payroll employees were just crushed last month via a drop of 97,800 and this was almost fully offset by a coincidental surge of 86,900 in the number of self-employed," said Scotiabank's Derek Holt in a note to clients Friday. "That’s statistically possible I suppose but it looks very fishy to me."
Derek Holt, VP at Scotiank Economics, urged clients on Friday to approach Statistics Canada’s latest reading on the country’s labour market with caution, calling some details in the report “very fishy.”
According to the agency, the Canadian economy unexpectedly lost 11,000 jobs in August from July, and the number of private-sector employees fell sharply.
The fall of 111,800 in the number of private-sector employees amounted to 1.0%, equaling the record month-on-month drop in April 1982. Overall, 97,800 employees lost their jobs, while the number of self-employed rose by 86,900.
“Guess what? We again advise clients to be very careful with the Canadian jobs numbers,” said Holt in a note that comes just two weeks or so after Statistics Canada issued an unprecedented and massive revision of its July jobs report.
“Apparently private payroll employees were just crushed last month via a drop of 97,800 and this was almost fully offset by a coincidental surge of 86,900 in the number of self-employed,” Holt continued. “That’s statistically possible I suppose but it looks very fishy to me.”
Holt added: “The rise in the number of self-employed and the 111,800 drop in private payrolls are both monthly records in figures stretching back to the survey’s inception in 1976. What an utterly fascinating pair of coincidences.”
July’s amended report showed that 42,000 jobs were created, not a measly 200 as originally reported.
Gluskin-Sheff chief economist David Rosenberg also said Friday’s report did “not quite pass the smell test.”
Rosenberg, like Holt, casts a critical eye at the largest monthly decline in private sector jobs on record — even bigger than biggest decline at the peak of the recession (100,000 jobs lost in January 2009).
“The loss of a record number of private sector jobs during an expansion seems odd to say the least,” wrote Rosenberg in his morning note.
jobs
At the same time, “self-employment jumped 87,000 to mark its largest increase on record.”
“Of the decline in private sector employment, the vast majority of it occurred in Ontario (-43,000) and Quebec (-36,000) with no clear industry being the driver. This all seems very strange and leads us to take the report with a giant grain of salt.”

AND

Private sector pummelled as Canada sheds 11,000 jobs in August

Employment in Canada’s private sector is at a standstill.
While monthly employment readings have seesawed through the year, one trend is clear: Private companies are in no mood to hire, having shed a record 111,800 jobs in August, according to Statistics Canada.
Month-to-month measures have been volatile but the longer-term view shows full-time and private positions have barely budged in a year, while eight in 10 new jobs have been part-time.

MORE RELATED TO THIS STORY

The numbers seem at odds with other indicators that show strengthening exports, solid housing starts and retail sales that have climbed for six consecutive months. But the tepid hiring reflects caution among employers grappling with competitive pressures, uneven global demand and rapid shifts in many of their business models.
Greg Wight, for one, the chief executive officer of Algoma Central Corp., the largest operator of dry-bulk vessels on the Great Lakes-St. Lawrence Seaway, has seen fairly robust demand this year.
Activity is strong in shipping iron ore for the steel industry, while his vessels are also moving more grain and salt. He’s optimistic, but said volatility in demand is causing uncertainty.
Algoma has invested millions of dollars in purchasing ships that will boost productivity by going faster and carrying more cargo. But that doesn’t mean he’s planning a hiring spree. If anything, “we can operate with fewer crew members because of technological improvements,” he said.
In recent years, the services sector has been the main driver of jobs growth. Now, though, many of the sectors benefiting from a pickup in demand, such as manufacturing and information technology, may not need a big influx of workers as they ramp up output, said Randall Bartlett, senior economist at Toronto-Dominion Bank.
Employment numbers have been turbulent all year, with job gains in one month followed by losses in the next. Smoothing out the monthly bumps, employers have added a paltry 10,400 jobs per month on average so far this year.
All told, the Canadian economy shed 11,000 jobs last month, while the jobless rate remained at 7 per cent as more people exited the labour force, Statistics Canada said Friday.
Private-sector hiring tumbled as the manufacturing, trade and professional services sectors cut jobs. The share of people working in manufacturing has ebbed to a record low this summer. The public sector added 14,000 jobs and self employment rose by 86,900, a record gain.
The outsized readings on private-sector losses and self-employment gains raised eyebrows. Bank of Nova Scotia economists Derek Holt and Dov Zigler called the numbers “very fishy” and advised clients to be “very careful” in drawing conclusions from the monthly data.
Skepticism over the data comes after the agency was forced to correct its July jobs numbers. That month saw a gain of 41,700 positions rather than the 200 jobs it had originally reported, a mistake attributed to an incomplete understanding of changes that occurred in the redesign of its survey.
The broader picture shows employment levels in the private sector “has been relatively flat since the fall of 2013,” Statistics Canada observed.
In the past few months, companies including Bombardier Inc., Rogers Communications and Transcontinental have announced layoffs, along with multinational firms, such as Cisco Systems and Microsoft. At the same time, restraint remains in the public sector with the federal government continuing to trim payrolls.
The Bank of Canada has recently flagged the weak performance in the jobs market, saying the prevalence of part-time positions is a “symptom of slack” in the labour market. In its interest-rate statement this week, the central bank said that, although the country’s export sectors “appear to be turning the corner,” this pickup will need to be sustained before it translates into more hiring.
Young people in particular have seen little improvement on the employment front. The average jobless rates for students this summer was little changed from the previous year, while their average number of hours worked fell to 23.5 hours a week from 23.7 hours in the previous summer.
The country's participation rate fell to 66 per cent, the lowest since 2001, as 20,800 people left the labour force.
Comment:
"Worker Immigration for any specific trade can only be justified if there are in fact there is no unemployment problem in that particular trade.

The attached three articles about Canada’s unemployment statistics go to the heart of a serious problem … no one can believe Ottawa’s statistics.

  • It speaks to the government’s integrity when senior bank economists refer to Ottawa’s unemployment numbers as “fishy”.

The concern with Ottawa numbers reached its ultimate Mickey Mouse moment on June 20, 2014.  Ministers Kenney and Alexander issued formal statements confirming that Ottawa would have good statistics for foreign worker purposes in the spring of 2015.

Have a look at Kenney’s and Alexander’s below statements from June 20, 2014. 

Think of it ….. for the past year , these two Ministers have been telling legitimate Canadian employers that  there are unemployed Canadian construction workers, ethnic cooks and automotive  technicians.

Ministers are sworn to tell the truth.  Meanwhile on June 20, these two senior representatives of Her Majesty brazenly admitted that they will not have reliable statistics concnering unemployed tradespersons until the spring of 2015.

To make matters worse, experienced sources tell me that Ottawa does in fact have very reliable unemployment statistics for unemployed tradespersons.

So why misrepresent the truth …twice?

Because in the Alice in Wonderland of federal politics, agendas matter.

In Ottawa, statistics don’t matter. Truth doesn’t matter. Policy does not matter. Law does not matter …..  Agendas matter.

Jason Kenney has one agenda... the 2015 election.

And only one statistic matters... the number 18

18% of existing Canadians must be made to believe that Jason and Chris are defending Canadian jobs against hoards of law abiding would be new Canadians.

If 18% of Canadians don’t buy the story then keep throwing more cow dung against the wall in the hope that something eventually sticks… as long as 18 % eventually buy the nonsense and vote accordingly  then Jason will have done his job

Why 18%?

Because about half of Canadians vote in federal elections. That means that 18% of actual voters equates a 36% formal vote. In turn, this means that the party would be electorally competitive with 18%.

Bottom line: If you’re not in the blessed 18% , get lost."
Richard Boraks 

No comments:

Post a Comment